Upcoming Games

(UTC times)


Full list
Add a game

Upcoming Events

No events to display

Timetable Chaining Assistant.

You are here: Home > Forum > Wishlist > Features wish list > Timetable Chaining Assistant.

Page 1 of 1

Timetable Chaining Assistant. 01/06/2023 at 12:26 #152008
Guts
Avatar
604 posts
Online
Would it be possible to have a Timetable Chaining Assist, that can adjust timetables to match across different Sims.

For example if I have a Leeds East/West timetable but Leeds Ardsley doesn't have an equal timetable, i can click an option that changes Leeds Ardsley's timetable at the appropriate entry/exit point to match, saving it automatically as an editted timetable, so as not to overwrite the original.

Obviously, this will or should be able to flag up conflicts in a report where there are clashes, which would then have to be resolved. These clashes will be a lot easier to resolve than the current line by line manual method I have to use to match up timetables to enable Chaining (or bigger Chains)

I don't know if it helps; this might be easier facilitated if the Sims are chained while the process is carried out, so the Sims are already talking t each other.

Thanks Guts

Log in to reply
Timetable Chaining Assistant. 01/06/2023 at 12:37 #152011
postal
Avatar
5264 posts
There is something that goes halfway to what you want. Jamie Stallwood (forum handle 9pN1SEAp) has written an XML comparison tool which checks the interface between two linked TTs as standalones rather than while running in sim. See this topic.

While the tool doesn't correct the TTs, it does list the discrepancies so that the TTs can be manually edited. The tool is available at this link.

I don't think there is a manual available so you have to play until you've fathomed how it all works but it does enable a very quick comparison between TTs and is rather a nice piece of work.

“In life, there is always someone out there, who won’t like you, for whatever reason, don’t let the insecurities in their lives affect yours.” – Rashida Rowe
Log in to reply
The following user said thank you: Guts
Timetable Chaining Assistant. 01/06/2023 at 12:49 #152014
Guts
Avatar
604 posts
Online
postal in post 152011 said:
There is something that goes halfway to what you want. Jamie Stallwood (forum handle 9pN1SEAp) has written an XML comparison tool which checks the interface between two linked TTs as standalones rather than while running in sim. See this topic.

While the tool doesn't correct the TTs, it does list the discrepancies so that the TTs can be manually edited. The tool is available at this link.

I don't think there is a manual available so you have to play until you've fathomed how it all works but it does enable a very quick comparison between TTs and is rather a nice piece of work.
Technically, I'm already doing this. I choose the Exit of one Sim and the Entry of the other Sim and I work my way through each train. I then change over and do it the other way.
It's long and tedious. Takes weeks around work and home life to complete. I was hoping there might be some automation that could be built in.

Log in to reply
Timetable Chaining Assistant. 01/06/2023 at 14:33 #152016
postal
Avatar
5264 posts
Guts in post 152014 said:
postal in post 152011 said:
There is something that goes halfway to what you want. Jamie Stallwood (forum handle 9pN1SEAp) has written an XML comparison tool which checks the interface between two linked TTs as standalones rather than while running in sim. See this topic.

While the tool doesn't correct the TTs, it does list the discrepancies so that the TTs can be manually edited. The tool is available at this link.

I don't think there is a manual available so you have to play until you've fathomed how it all works but it does enable a very quick comparison between TTs and is rather a nice piece of work.
Technically, I'm already doing this. I choose the Exit of one Sim and the Entry of the other Sim and I work my way through each train. I then change over and do it the other way.
It's long and tedious. Takes weeks around work and home life to complete. I was hoping there might be some automation that could be built in.
But Jamie's comparison tool automates the process of ploughing on comparing things line by line. That tool looks at the two TTs and compares every train across the interface(s) flagging up wherever there is a difference so that it has already done your line by line comparison. The output is a report which you can put into a spreadsheet and manipulate so that only the TTs which differ across the interface are flagged up. You (hopefully) then have only a small number of questionable items to go through and amend rather than three or four hundred lines of timetable. Last time I ran it was a good while ago, comparing Edinburgh 2006 and Motherwell 2006 and I had the output in less than 30 seconds, copied from browser into spreadsheet filtered to only show variances in about a minute and all TT amendments done within 10 minutes.

“In life, there is always someone out there, who won’t like you, for whatever reason, don’t let the insecurities in their lives affect yours.” – Rashida Rowe
Last edited: 01/06/2023 at 14:36 by postal
Reason: None given

Log in to reply
The following users said thank you: jc92, Guts
Timetable Chaining Assistant. 01/06/2023 at 20:02 #152020
9pN1SEAp
Avatar
1180 posts
Online
postal in post 152011 said:
I don't think there is a manual available so you have to play until you've fathomed how it all works but it does enable a very quick comparison between TTs and is rather a nice piece of work.
Alas not, hopefully it's fairly intuitive but drop me a PM if there be any queries.

Thanks
Jamie

Jamie S (JAMS)
Log in to reply
Timetable Chaining Assistant. 01/07/2023 at 11:03 #152282
Guts
Avatar
604 posts
Online
postal in post 152016 said:
Guts in post 152014 said:
postal in post 152011 said:
There is something that goes halfway to what you want. Jamie Stallwood (forum handle 9pN1SEAp) has written an XML comparison tool which checks the interface between two linked TTs as standalones rather than while running in sim. See this topic.

While the tool doesn't correct the TTs, it does list the discrepancies so that the TTs can be manually edited. The tool is available at this link.

I don't think there is a manual available so you have to play until you've fathomed how it all works but it does enable a very quick comparison between TTs and is rather a nice piece of work.
Technically, I'm already doing this. I choose the Exit of one Sim and the Entry of the other Sim and I work my way through each train. I then change over and do it the other way.
It's long and tedious. Takes weeks around work and home life to complete. I was hoping there might be some automation that could be built in.
But Jamie's comparison tool automates the process of ploughing on comparing things line by line. That tool looks at the two TTs and compares every train across the interface(s) flagging up wherever there is a difference so that it has already done your line by line comparison. The output is a report which you can put into a spreadsheet and manipulate so that only the TTs which differ across the interface are flagged up. You (hopefully) then have only a small number of questionable items to go through and amend rather than three or four hundred lines of timetable. Last time I ran it was a good while ago, comparing Edinburgh 2006 and Motherwell 2006 and I had the output in less than 30 seconds, copied from browser into spreadsheet filtered to only show variances in about a minute and all TT amendments done within 10 minutes.
Maybe it's just me but i'm not finding the interface easier

Log in to reply
Timetable Chaining Assistant. 01/07/2023 at 19:23 #152284
postal
Avatar
5264 posts
Guts in post 152282 said:
Maybe it's just me but i'm not finding the interface easier
Spreadsheet I put together a couple of years ago attached: The instructions are on the first tab of the spreadsheet. I haven't tried it recently but hopefully it will still work. Any problems, PM me.

As ever, you download at your own risk.

Post has attachments. Log in to view them.
“In life, there is always someone out there, who won’t like you, for whatever reason, don’t let the insecurities in their lives affect yours.” – Rashida Rowe
Last edited: 01/07/2023 at 19:24 by postal
Reason: None given

Log in to reply