Upcoming Games

No games to display

Full list
Add a game

Upcoming Events

No events to display

Bugs: Accepting wrong routes & passing signals at danger

You are here: Home > Forum > Simulations > Released > Huyton & St Helens > Bugs: Accepting wrong routes & passing signals at danger

Page 1 of 1

Bugs: Accepting wrong routes & passing signals at danger 12/02/2024 at 00:51 #155296
lucya
Avatar
19 posts
Thank you to the dev(s) for sorting the TD stepping & timetabling issues in the recent update!

I've found three bugs in the pre-2014 version (possibly also 2014), and have attached the save file just after the train took the wrong route.
-Trains pass Cowley Hill GF 5 signal at danger when the points are set, rather than waiting for the signal.
-Cowley Hill GF 5 signal is not visible unless the GF is released. Not sure if intentional?
-Trains booked via Ravenhead Junction will accept a route towards Huyton do not challenge the route.

I then investigated if trains would accept any other wrong routes and found that:
-Trains booked to head to Warrington will accept a route into Cowley Hill.
-Trains booked to head into Cowley Hill will accept a route towards Warrington.

Also, following some brief research, irl Cowley Hill ground frame's signal cannot be pulled off unless SH17 signal is also cleared. The lever for GF5 appears to be electrically released by SH24 lever, and the pull plate is marked "9, 12, 17". I know other sims have signals that need to be cleared first, not sure how difficult this would be to implement?

Not hugely game-breaking bugs but I'd appreciate if they were looked into! Thanks.

Post has attachments. Log in to view them.
Log in to reply
Bugs: Accepting wrong routes & passing signals at danger 28/03/2024 at 17:15 #155886
lucya
Avatar
19 posts
Just going to bump this as it doesn't appear to have been looked at!
Log in to reply
Bugs: Accepting wrong routes & passing signals at danger 28/03/2024 at 19:29 #155888
pedroathome
Avatar
916 posts
lucya in post 155296 said:
Thank you to the dev(s) for sorting the TD stepping & timetabling issues in the recent update!

I've found three bugs in the pre-2014 version (possibly also 2014), and have attached the save file just after the train took the wrong route.
-Trains pass Cowley Hill GF 5 signal at danger when the points are set, rather than waiting for the signal.
-Cowley Hill GF 5 signal is not visible unless the GF is released. Not sure if intentional?
-Trains booked via Ravenhead Junction will accept a route towards Huyton do not challenge the route.

I then investigated if trains would accept any other wrong routes and found that:
-Trains booked to head to Warrington will accept a route into Cowley Hill.
-Trains booked to head into Cowley Hill will accept a route towards Warrington.

Also, following some brief research, irl Cowley Hill ground frame's signal cannot be pulled off unless SH17 signal is also cleared. The lever for GF5 appears to be electrically released by SH24 lever, and the pull plate is marked "9, 12, 17". I know other sims have signals that need to be cleared first, not sure how difficult this would be to implement?

Not hugely game-breaking bugs but I'd appreciate if they were looked into! Thanks.
Mantis 40614

Apologies for missing this first time around. I agree that there are issues here, and will take a look at it over the weekend

James

Log in to reply
The following user said thank you: lucya